Owner's Contracts The clauses that decide what happens when it goes wrong.

Owner's Contracts

TRANSFERABILITY

Assignment Clauses, and Why a Lender Reads Them First

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

An assignment clause decides whether your contracts can move to a buyer or a lender, which is why it gets read before the price and the term.

A lender asked for your five largest customer agreements. You expected questions about pricing or term length. Instead the first thing anybody turned to was a short clause near the back headed Assignment. Why there?

Because that clause decides whether your contracts can move. Move to a buyer when you sell. Move to a lender as collateral. Move to a surviving company after a merger, or to the new entity when you reorganize. A book of revenue that cannot travel is worth less than the same revenue that can, and a contract that hands your customer a termination right the moment ownership changes is a liability sitting inside an asset.

Read the clause yourself before anybody else does. It's usually six lines long and it is doing more work than the pricing schedule.

Assignment covers two different things

Underneath the single word are two separate moves, and most clauses blur them.

Assigning a right means handing somebody else the benefit you were owed, most often the right to be paid. Delegating a duty means handing somebody else the obligation to perform. Under general contract principles rights are freely assignable and duties are freely delegable, with exceptions, and the biggest exception is that a duty depending on somebody's personal skill or judgment cannot be handed off without consent.

There is a consequence of that split which surprises people. Delegating your duties does not release you from them. The other party can still come to you if the substitute performs badly. Getting released requires a novation, which is a new contract among all three parties replacing you outright, and a novation is something the counterparty has to agree to rather than something you can do by assignment.

Then there is the phrase by operation of law, which usually appears in the list of things that count as an assignment. It reaches transfers that happen automatically, including some mergers. Whether a particular merger triggers a consent requirement can turn on how the deal is structured, because in some structures the contracting entity survives and in others it does not. Courts have reached different results on different structures and in different states, which is exactly why deal lawyers spend real money on this question. For an owner, the practical takeaway is that the words by operation of law are worth noticing, and that how you structure a sale can decide whether a clause fires at all.

And an assignment clause is not the same as a change of control clause. A change of control provision is triggered when ownership of your company shifts, whether or not any contract is transferred anywhere. Selling the equity of the business can sail right past the assignment clause and land on the change of control clause instead. A document with both has two separate tripwires.

Why a lender turns to it first

Three things a lender is checking, and none of them are about whether you are a good business.

The first is collateral quality. If your receivables secure the loan, the lender needs to know the underlying agreements do not block that. Here the law is friendlier than most contracts are: the Uniform Commercial Code makes terms restricting the assignment of accounts and payment intangibles ineffective against a security interest, so a bare anti-assignment clause generally cannot stop a lender taking your receivables as collateral. The rule has edges and it does not reach every kind of right, so it is a starting point rather than an answer.

The second is contract survival. A lender underwriting against contracted revenue wants to know the revenue survives the transaction. A change of control clause giving your biggest customer a termination right on closing turns projected cash flow into a maybe. That clause gets flagged in every loan file it appears in.

The third is government work. Federal contracts run under their own rules, and transferring one is not a private matter between you and anyone else. There is a statutory restriction on assigning government contracts and claims, a recognized process for substituting a successor through a formal novation with the contracting officer, and a separate framework allowing payments to be assigned to a financing institution under stated conditions. If your revenue includes federal work, that is its own workstream in any financing or sale.

The consent trap, and the word that makes it bite

Most clauses do not forbid assignment outright. They require the other party's prior written consent. What follows the word consent is where the value sits.

If the clause stops there, the counterparty has absolute discretion. They can say no for any reason, or for no reason, or say nothing at all. A customer with absolute discretion over your sale holds a free option, and the moment to exercise it is the week before your closing date, when their bargaining position is at its strongest. Add the words not to be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed and the discretion becomes reviewable.

Better still, add a clock. A provision deeming consent given if the counterparty does not respond within a stated number of business days converts silence from a weapon into a formality. Ask for the clock. It is a small request and it is the difference between a transaction and a hostage negotiation.

There is also a drafting detail that decides what happens if an assignment goes ahead without consent. A clause that merely prohibits assignment often produces a breach, meaning the assignment still worked and the counterparty has a claim. A clause saying an assignment made without consent is void or of no effect can invalidate the transfer itself. One word, two very different outcomes, and the version in your contract is a coin flip unless you look.

The clause to fear is not the one that says no. It is the one that says nothing about how long they can take to answer.

What to put in the clause

What it costs when it is wrong

Take a services business where roughly a third of recurring revenue sits under agreements requiring written consent to assignment, with no reasonableness standard and no response deadline. A buyer looking at that will do one of three things. Restructure the deal to avoid triggering the clauses. Hold back a slice of the purchase price until the consents arrive. Or reduce the price to account for the revenue that might walk.

Each of those costs the seller money, and all of it was decided years earlier by a clause nobody negotiated because it looked like formatting.

The repair is cheap and boring. Pull your ten largest agreements. Read the assignment clause, the change of control clause and the termination clause in each one, together, in a single sitting. Write down which ones would fire on a sale and which ones a lender would flag. That list is a to-do list for the next renewal, and renewal is the only moment when changing the language costs nothing.

Common questions

Can I sell my business if my contracts say no assignment without consent?

You can, and the clause changes how the sale gets structured and priced. An asset sale transfers agreements one at a time, so every consent requirement becomes an approval to chase, while an equity sale may avoid the assignment clause entirely unless the contract also carries a change of control provision. Buyers routinely hold back part of the price until the consents that matter are signed.

Does an anti-assignment clause stop me from using invoices as collateral?

Usually it does not. The Uniform Commercial Code makes contract terms restricting the assignment of accounts ineffective against a security interest, which is why a lender can take receivables as collateral even where the underlying agreement forbids assignment. That rule has edges, it does not reach every category of contract right, and federal government work runs under separate statutes.

What is the difference between assignment and a change of control clause?

An assignment clause fires when the contract itself is transferred to somebody else. A change of control clause fires when ownership of your company changes, even though no contract has moved anywhere. A stock sale can pass straight by the assignment clause and land on the change of control clause, which is why both need reading before a deal is structured.

More on this