THE LEASE
The Personal Guarantee Buried in a Commercial Lease
A guaranty in a lease is a second contract signed by you personally, and the landlord never has to pierce the entity because you already signed twice.
You formed an LLC so the company's obligations would stay with the company. Then you signed a lease, and somewhere past page fifteen there is a paragraph with your own name in it, followed by a signature line that says individually.
That paragraph undoes the entity for this one obligation. A guaranty is a second contract, between you personally and the landlord, in which you promise to pay if the tenant does not. Nobody has to argue about piercing anything or about whether you kept the company's formalities straight. You signed twice, so there are two people on the hook, and one of them is you.
For a lot of small businesses this is the largest financial commitment the owner has ever made, and it gets signed in the same fifteen minutes as the parking rules.
Where it hides in the document
It's rarely in the part of the lease anybody reads carefully.
Sometimes it is a separate exhibit at the back, headed Guaranty of Lease, formatted like an attachment and easy to read as boilerplate. Sometimes it is a single sentence in the lease body saying the tenant's obligations are guaranteed by a named individual, with the guaranty terms defined elsewhere.
The subtlest version is the signature page. You sign once for the entity, under a line reading its name and your title. Then there is a second block underneath, and that one has no title on it. Signing the second block is signing personally, and the visual difference between the two is a missing word.
There is also the version that arrives later. A lease amendment, a renewal, or a consent to assignment can carry a fresh guaranty or reaffirm an old one. An owner who negotiated a limited guaranty at signing can hand back an unlimited one three years later by initialing a renewal.
The words that decide how big it is
Payment or collection. A guaranty of collection requires the landlord to pursue the tenant first and come up short before turning to you. A guaranty of payment lets the landlord skip that entirely and sue you directly on the first missed month. Nearly all commercial guaranties are written as guaranties of payment and performance, often reinforced by a line calling you a primary obligor rather than a surety. That line is there to remove every argument that you should be second in line.
The waiver block. Most guaranties contain a dense paragraph waiving notice, waiving defenses, and waiving any objection to changes in the underlying lease. Read that one twice. It means the landlord and the tenant can amend the lease, extend the term, expand the premises or raise the rent, and your guaranty follows along without anyone telling you. If your business partner renegotiates the lease after you have left the company, that paragraph is why you are still bound.
Continuing. A continuing guaranty covers renewals, extensions and holdover periods rather than the original term alone. An owner who thinks the exposure ends in five years may be guaranteeing a relationship with no fixed end.
Joint and several. If two owners both guarantee, the landlord may collect the entire amount from whichever one has money and leave the two of you to sort out the rest between yourselves. Being the partner with assets is a risk factor in its own right here.
Procedural terms. Waivers of jury trial are routine. Consent to jurisdiction in the landlord's home state is routine. A confession of judgment provision, which allows a judgment to be entered against you without a hearing, exists in commercial documents in some states and is prohibited or tightly restricted in others. If you see one, that alone is worth a call to a lawyer before signing.
The size of the number
Guaranty exposure is usually not one missed month. It is whatever the lease says the landlord may recover on default, and leases are drafted to recover a lot.
Take a suite at 6,500 dollars a month with five years left to run. Base rent alone across that remaining term is 390,000 dollars. Add the tenant's share of operating costs, property taxes and insurance, which in a lease structured that way are additional rent and fall inside the guaranty. Add brokerage commissions and construction allowances the landlord may be entitled to claw back. Add the cost of preparing the space for the next tenant, and the landlord's legal fees, since the fee shifting clause runs one direction in most lease forms.
Whether the landlord must try to re-let the space before collecting the whole thing from you depends on the state. Some jurisdictions require commercial landlords to make reasonable efforts to mitigate. Others leave the landlord free to let the space sit and bill the guarantor. That single point of state law can double the number, and it is not something to guess at.
Acceleration turns a monthly problem into a single judgment. Read the default section and the guaranty together, because that is how the landlord will read them.
Five ways to make it smaller
None of this requires refusing to sign. It requires asking for a shape.
- A dollar cap. The guaranty is limited to a stated maximum. Simple, easy for a landlord to evaluate, and the most common concession available.
- A time cap. Liability covers the first eighteen or twenty-four months rather than the full term. After that the landlord relies on the entity and the deposit.
- A burn down. The cap reduces each year the tenant pays on time, reaching zero at some point in the term. This is the version landlords accept most readily, because it rewards exactly the behavior they want.
- A surrender condition. Often called a good guy guaranty. Personal liability stops if you give the required notice, vacate by the stated date in the required condition and pay everything owed through surrender. You remain responsible for the time you occupied and not for the balance of the term. The conditions are strict and are read strictly.
- Cash instead. Offer a larger security deposit or a letter of credit in exchange for dropping the guaranty or shrinking it. You are trading working capital for personal exposure, which is sometimes a very good trade and sometimes a terrible one, but it is a real negotiation the landlord understands.
Also worth asking for: a carve out excluding the landlord's attorney fees and re-letting costs, so the guaranty covers rent rather than the whole litigation. And a release tied to an objective test, such as the tenant maintaining a stated net worth for a stated period.
Selling the business does not end it
This is where owners get hurt years after the fact.
Assigning the lease to a buyer transfers the tenant's obligations to the buyer. It does not release the guarantor. Unless the landlord signs a written release of the guaranty, you are still standing behind a lease for a business you no longer own, operated by somebody whose decisions you do not control. Worse, a continuing guaranty with a broad waiver block may follow the lease into amendments the new owner negotiates.
Get the release in writing at closing, as a signed document from the landlord naming you and stating that your obligations end on the closing date. If the landlord will not release you, know that before you price the deal, and make the buyer indemnify you as a fallback. An indemnity from a buyer is worth whatever the buyer is worth, which may be very little by the time it matters.
And keep a copy of the guaranty somewhere you can find it. The single most common answer owners give when asked what their personal exposure on the lease is: they are not sure, and the document is in a box.
Common questions
Can I get out of a personal guarantee on a lease?
Only by agreement with the landlord, or by satisfying a release condition the document already contains. Some guaranties end when you surrender the space properly and pay everything owed through the surrender date, some step down after a run of on time payments, and many have no exit written into them at all. Read the guaranty as its own document, because the release language lives there rather than in the lease.
Does my LLC protect me if I signed a personal guarantee?
No, and the entity is not failing you when that happens. An LLC shields you from obligations of the company that you never personally promised, and a guaranty is a promise made in your own name on a separate contract. The landlord does not need to argue about the entity at all, because there are two signatures and two agreements.
What is a good guy guarantee?
It is a limited guaranty used in some commercial markets, under which personal liability stops if the tenant gives the required notice, hands back the space in the agreed condition and is current on everything owed through the surrender date. It covers the period you actually occupied rather than the balance of the term. The conditions are strict and get read strictly, so a late notice or one unpaid charge can leave the full guaranty standing.