Owner's Contracts The clauses that decide what happens when it goes wrong.

Owner's Contracts

EXPOSURE

Limitation of Liability: The Two Caps That Decide the Exposure

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

A limitation of liability section sets a number on what you can owe and deletes whole categories of loss, and the second cap usually matters more.

Somebody told you the contract is fine because liability is capped at fees paid. That is one of two caps in the section, and the other one decides whether the first ever matters.

A limitation of liability clause does two separate jobs. It puts a number on the most you can be made to pay, and it deletes entire categories of loss from the argument before anyone counts anything. The second job is usually worth more money than the first, and it is the one owners skim past because it reads like a list of adjectives.

Here is the whole section in two sentences. Cap one says how much. Cap two says what kind.

Cap one: the number, and how it behaves over time

The dollar cap comes in a handful of shapes. Fees paid under the agreement in the twelve months before the claim. Total fees paid under the agreement, ever. A fixed figure written into the contract. The amount of insurance you are required to carry. Sometimes the greater of two of those, sometimes the lesser, and the difference between greater and lesser is worth reading twice.

The trailing twelve month version is everywhere, and it has a behavior owners rarely think through: the cap moves. It is small at the start of a relationship, it grows, and then it shrinks again as the work winds down.

Take a service running at 4,000 dollars a month. At steady state the trailing twelve months hold 48,000 dollars, and that is the ceiling on what your counterparty could recover from you, or you from them. Now move the failure to the second month of the contract. Fees paid in the preceding twelve months come to 4,000 dollars, so that is the entire cap, on a relationship both sides expect to run for years.

Now move it the other way. The contract ended eight months ago and a claim arrives about work done in the final quarter. The trailing twelve months from the claim date hold four months of fees, which is 16,000 dollars. The work that generated the claim was worth three times that.

If you're the one being protected by the cap, this shape is excellent. If you are the one relying on it to make you whole, it is a ceiling that falls exactly when you need headroom. Ask for a fixed number, or for annualized contract value, or for a floor underneath the trailing calculation.

Cap two: the categories that get deleted

The second half of the section usually reads something like this: neither party is liable for indirect, incidental, special, consequential or punitive damages, including lost profits, lost revenue, loss of data, loss of goodwill or interruption of business, even if advised of the possibility.

That sentence is a cap set at zero for the losses that hurt most.

Direct damages are the immediate cost of the breach. You paid somebody else more to finish the job, and the difference is direct. Consequential damages are what happened downstream because of the breach. The line went down for nine days. The seasonal order shipped after the season. The customer left.

For a buyer of services, downstream loss is almost always the real loss. A mutual exclusion of consequential damages sounds even handed and it usually is not, because the vendor's exposure lives in that category and the buyer's fee exposure does not. Which is precisely why vendors want the clause and why it is the single most defended sentence in commercial drafting.

The boundary between direct and consequential is not crisp, and it has been argued since long before anybody wrote a software contract. Lost profits are the hardest case: profit lost on the very transaction in question is often treated as direct, while profit lost on other business is usually consequential. Courts do not agree about this consistently, and the drafting fix is to stop relying on the labels and name the specific categories you mean, in or out.

Watch the phrase even if advised of the possibility. It is there to kill the foreseeability argument, which is the oldest route a claimant has into downstream loss. Without those words, a buyer who warned you in writing about the production deadline has an argument that the loss was in contemplation when the deal was struck. With them, the warning stops counting for much.

A mutual exclusion of consequential damages is only mutual on paper. It protects whoever has the downstream loss.

The carve-outs are where the cap leaks

Most limitation clauses end with a list of things the caps do not apply to. Read that list as the real exposure map of the contract, because everything named there is uncapped.

The usual candidates:

Some of these cannot be capped anyway. Courts in many states refuse to enforce a limitation against fraud or willful misconduct as a matter of public policy, so a carve-out for those is often just writing down what the law already does.

One more question to ask of the number itself: is it a per claim ceiling or an aggregate ceiling across the whole life of the agreement? Aggregate is the usual drafting and it is the tighter of the two. A per claim cap on a long relationship with recurring small failures is a different animal, and the word doing all that work is a single adjective you can miss in one reading.

The rest of the carve-outs are negotiable, and the middle ground is the secondary cap. Instead of leaving a category uncapped, the parties agree to a higher ceiling for that category: a multiple of the general cap, or a number tied to the insurance actually carried. That gives the buyer meaningful recovery without handing the vendor an obligation nobody can insure or survive.

What makes a cap stand up when it is tested

Three things matter more than the drafting elegance.

Conspicuousness. This is why limitation clauses are set in capital letters or bold type. For sales of goods, the Uniform Commercial Code requires that a disclaimer of implied warranties be conspicuous, and courts have applied similar thinking to liability limits generally. A cap hidden in the middle of a dense paragraph is easier to attack than the same words in a heading of their own.

Mutuality and bargaining. A cap in a negotiated agreement between two businesses is on much firmer ground than the same cap in a form nobody could edit. If you negotiated the section, keep the redlines. They are evidence that the allocation was bargained for.

Failure of essential purpose. If the contract gives a single exclusive remedy, repair and replacement being the classic one, and that remedy never actually fixes anything, a court can set it aside. The hard question is what happens to the consequential damages exclusion when that occurs, and courts split. Drafting that keeps the exclusion standing independently of the remedy is one answer, though no clause survives every judge.

And a practical note that has nothing to do with law. A cap is only as good as the entity standing behind it. A generous cap in a contract with a thinly capitalized subsidiary is a number on paper. Before you spend a week negotiating the ceiling upward, find out whether there is anything underneath it.

Common questions

What is the difference between direct and consequential damages?

Direct damages are the loss that flows straight from the breach, such as paying somebody else more to finish the same work. Consequential damages are the knock-on losses further downstream, such as revenue you never earned because the work arrived late. The line between the two gets argued constantly, which is why careful clauses name specific categories instead of trusting the labels.

Is a cap of fees paid in the last twelve months reasonable?

It is the most common shape in services agreements, and whether it is reasonable depends on how that number behaves at the moment something goes wrong. Early in a contract, or well after one has wound down, the trailing window can hold very little money. Ask for a fixed figure, an annualized contract value or a floor underneath the calculation so the ceiling does not collapse at the point you need it.

Can a limitation of liability clause be thrown out?

Sometimes. Courts in many states refuse to enforce a cap against fraud or willful misconduct, and a clause buried in unreadable type has a harder time than one presented clearly under its own heading. There is also the failure of essential purpose problem, where an exclusive remedy that never remedies anything can put the rest of the section at risk. None of that is reliable enough to plan around.

More on this