RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS
Non-Compete vs. Non-Solicit, and What Changed
A non-compete stops someone working, a non-solicit stops them taking your customers, and the federal ban announced in 2024 never took effect.
Your agreement has one paragraph saying a departing salesperson cannot work for a competitor for a year. It has another saying they cannot call your customers. Those are two different restrictions and they are not enforced the same way.
A non-compete stops a person from working. A non-solicit stops them from approaching specific relationships while leaving them free to earn a living in the same trade. The second is narrower, holds up in more places, and protects most of what an owner actually cares about losing. If you get to keep one of the two paragraphs, it's usually the second one.
And the ground under both moved recently. A federal ban on most non-competes was announced in 2024 and was set aside by a court before its effective date arrived, so it never applied to anyone. What that left behind is state law, which has been changing fast and now varies more between states than it did ten years ago.
The federal chapter, briefly, because clients keep asking
In April 2024 the Federal Trade Commission issued a rule that would have voided most existing non-competes and banned new ones for almost all workers. Before the rule could take effect, a federal district court in Texas set it aside under the Administrative Procedure Act on a nationwide basis. The rule never operated. Appeals followed and were later abandoned by the agency, which said it would instead look at individual employers case by case.
Separately, the labor board's general counsel had issued a memo taking the position that overly broad non-competes for rank and file workers interfered with federal labor rights. That memo was withdrawn by a later general counsel.
So the enforcement posture at the federal level is unsettled and it is not a ban. The question of whether your clause works is answered by the law of the state where the worker actually works. Not where you incorporated, and not where the contract says.
Where state law has actually gone
Four patterns are worth knowing, because your clause probably meets at least one of them.
Outright voiding. A few states refuse to enforce employee non-competes as a matter of statute. California is the best known and has gone further than most, treating the restriction as void regardless of where it was signed and adding a route for the worker to sue over it. Minnesota voided new employee non-competes by statute in 2023. North Dakota and Oklahoma have taken the same position for a very long time.
Compensation floors. A number of states enforce these only above an earnings threshold, so the clause works on a sales director and is void on a delivery driver. The thresholds are set by statute and several of them adjust every year, so look up the current figure rather than the one in a memo from two years ago.
Process requirements. Some states require the agreement to be presented a set number of days before the job starts, or before the candidate accepts, and failing that timing kills the clause no matter how reasonable its terms are. Some require specific notice language.
Industry carve-outs. Healthcare has drawn particular legislative attention in several states, and a clause that binds an office manager may be unenforceable against a clinician in the same building.
Underneath all of it sits the older common law test, which most states still apply to whatever survives the statutes. A restriction has to protect something legitimate, has to be reasonable in duration and geography, and cannot be so broad that it simply stops someone from working. Some states will rewrite an overbroad clause to something reasonable. Others throw the whole thing out. Which of those your state does changes how aggressively it is worth drafting.
The non-solicit distinctions that decide the outcome
A non-solicit is easier to enforce, but only when it is drafted like a narrow protection rather than a non-compete in a different coat.
The customer version should be tied to customers the person actually worked with or learned about, over a defined lookback period, rather than every account in the company. A clause reaching customers the salesperson never heard of is asking a judge to notice that it is really a ban on competing.
Duration should track the sales cycle. If a customer relationship refreshes every quarter, a two year restriction is protecting something that no longer exists.
There is also the difference between soliciting and accepting. A non-solicit covers active approaches. The customer who calls the former employee unprompted often falls outside it. Some agreements add a non-acceptance clause to close that gap, and non-acceptance draws harder scrutiny because it restrains the customer's choice along with the worker's.
The staff version has its own problem, and it is a larger one than most owners realize. A promise by an employee not to recruit their former colleagues is one thing. An agreement between two companies that neither will hire the other's people is a different legal category entirely, and naked agreements of that kind among competitors have been treated as antitrust violations by federal enforcers, including criminally. If you have a no-hire promise sitting inside a vendor agreement or a staffing contract, that clause deserves a lawyer's eyes rather than a template's.
The clause you can enforce against a former employee is often unlawful when you make the same promise to a competitor.
Selling a business is a different world
Everything above concerns restrictions on people who work for you. Restrictions attached to the sale of a business run on a separate track.
When somebody buys a business, a large part of what they are paying for is goodwill, meaning the customers and reputation that came with it. A seller who takes the money and reopens across the street has sold something and kept it at the same time. Because of that, states that void employment non-competes routinely enforce a non-compete given by the seller of a business, within statutory limits on who can give one and how far it reaches.
The trap is the deal where the seller stays on as an employee. Now there are two agreements with two restrictive covenants under two different standards. The one in the purchase agreement may be enforceable while the one in the employment agreement is void, and if the drafting blurs them together you can end up with the weaker standard applied to both. Keep them in separate documents with separate consideration and say plainly which one is tied to the sale.
Restrictive covenants in operating agreements and partnership agreements sit somewhere in between, and the answer often turns on whether the person is being treated as an owner selling an interest or as a worker being restricted.
What protects you no matter which way the statute goes
Confidentiality holds up almost everywhere, provided it defines what is confidential instead of claiming everything is. A clause that sweeps in publicly available information tends to get narrowed or ignored.
Trade secret law works without any covenant at all, under both state law and the federal statute, for information you actually treated as secret. That last part is the whole test. Access controls and exit procedures are the evidence.
One technical requirement is easy to miss and costs real money. Federal trade secret law requires a specific whistleblower immunity notice in agreements governing use of trade secrets, and leaving it out forfeits your ability to recover exemplary damages and attorney fees under that statute. It is one paragraph. Check that your template has it.
Then there is the design of the pay. Commission structures that vest over time, clawbacks tied to accounts that leave within a window, and notice periods where the person stays on payroll and off the field do work that a covenant cannot, because none of them depend on a court agreeing with you afterward.
Common questions
Is my non-compete still enforceable after the FTC rule?
The rule announced in 2024 was set aside by a federal court before its effective date, so it never applied to anyone and your agreement is governed by state law exactly as it was before. What state law says has moved quickly, with several states voiding employee non-competes outright and others tying enforceability to earnings, notice timing or the industry. The answer turns on where the worker actually works, not on where your company is incorporated.
What is the difference between a non-solicit and a non-compete?
A non-compete restricts where a person may work at all. A non-solicit restricts them from approaching named relationships, usually your customers or your staff, while leaving them free to earn a living in the same field. Courts look on the narrower restriction far more favorably, and for most owners it protects the thing they actually care about.
Can I stop a former employee from taking clients who call them?
That takes a different clause. A non-solicit covers active approaches, so a customer who reaches out unprompted often falls outside it, which is why some agreements add a non-acceptance provision covering business the person never chased. Non-acceptance draws harder scrutiny because it restrains the customer's choice as much as the worker's, and some states will not enforce it at all.